RRSP vs TFSA, decided by what you actually earn
The rule everyone repeats breaks below a certain income. Here is where it breaks, and what to do instead.
An advertiser on this site sells products in this category.
Put money in the RRSP and you deduct it now, then pay tax when you take it out. Put it in the TFSA and you pay tax now, then take it out clean.
That trade only pays off one way. The RRSP wins when the rate you avoid today is higher than the rate you will pay later. If you are early in your career and your income is going up, today is your cheapest tax year, and deducting against it is spending a deduction at a discount.
Where the rule everyone repeats breaks
“Max the RRSP first” is advice written for someone in a high bracket. Below that, the deduction is worth little and the flexibility is worth a lot, because the TFSA lets you take the money back out and regain the room the following year. The RRSP does not. Money that goes in is money you are deciding not to need.
For a newcomer, there is a second thing that gets missed: RRSP room is built from income earned in Canada. In your first year you may have almost none, no matter what you are putting aside.
The version that survives contact
Keep the emergency fund in the TFSA, where you can reach it. Start the RRSP when your income reaches a bracket where the deduction actually buys something. Nobody gets punished for doing it in that order.